I think I'm seeing something between the messages here...
Just today I saw this video:
www.youtube.com/watc h?v=QAK0KXEpF8U
and immediately I thought about PDC, specifically this message thread. And it occurred to me that people may have stopped posting because of a certain fear. Not fear like life or death, but more like not wanting to get anyone riled up and have to deal with the aftermath. I'm guilty of it. I've started countless threads and replies, only to delete them, saying to myself "this might not go over well. Such and such person will probably say this or that."
I think that Joe's idea of creating incentives for us to post to the site is a wonderful idea, but then what happens after the event? Are we posting here because we wanted to be part of a community, or because we wanted to win the prize? I guess what I'm saying is that we should WANT to be here. We should ENJOY posting here.
When PDC started, we didn't have other options like Facebook and Reddit. Now we have to CHOOSE to come here. To make people do that, this place has to be hospitable, reasonable, and friendly.
There's been a lot of talk about overmoderation. Yes, there was a time when things were getting disrespectful and mean. Sadly, extreme measures had to take place with longtime members' accounts shut down. Some were friends of mine, and I hated having to tell them "I'm sorry. There's nothing I can do."
Seeing recent discussions though, I have observed that heated discussions CAN and DO take place without turning into a mosh pit of spears. I have chosen to sit back and watch several conversations to see where things go, and people have been policing themselves much better lately even in the heat of a pointed discussion. I hope this is an upward trend.
I have a point, believe it or not. And that is that it's up to us, the members, to make this place a success or a failure. Joe can sit in his Boss-man chair all day long giving out Klondike bars and propeller hats and shirts that say "I posted on PDC and all I got was this crappy t-shirt" but in the end it's you and me. We need to create an atmosphere where people want to be.