Thanks for all the suggestions. We had some from Schnucks tonight, and I wasn't impressed.
meanjarhead, where do you get the Witt's seasoning? I had never heard of it before.
@AnneC:
Wegmans carries it Zingermans and , Whole Food probably have it too and some people order it online. Stonewall Kitchen is another possible source.
It is well worth the effort to find it.